/Englkfz-tech.de

Search

A     B     C     D     E     F     G     H     I     J     K     L     M     N     O     P     Q     R     S     T     U     V     W     X     Y     Z


Formelsammlung
All Tests
 F7 F9




Battery technology 2020/2



kfz-tech.de/PeD6

Is it justifiable that a Tesla Model 3, when driven reasonably economically, averages 17 kW/100 km over the summer and winter, while a diesel vehicle averages 5 L/100 km? You might say that this would be a tiny bit to the detriment of the electric car, but please keep in mind that we want to compare the different powertrains, and to do so, we’d have to, just for the sake of the experiment, bring the diesel engine into the aerodynamically efficient Model 3. And that makes the assumptions a bit more likely after all.

Please be understanding; any value we choose can be criticized. I hope you'll agree that we now have values that are reasonably realistic. Another example, perhaps a more controversial one, would be to compare the losses associated with diesel fuel from the refinery to the tank and with electricity from the grid to the battery. Another example, perhaps a more controversial one, It is also difficult to quantify how much fuel or battery power is lost while the vehicle is stationary.

To put this in perspective: there are 8,760 hours in a year. If our cars travel 15,000 km per year, that would amount to 214 hours of pure driving time at an assumed average speed of 70 km/h, about 2.5 percent. In this competition, however, the electric car would be the big loser. No, we're not talking about Tesla and its enormous losses here. Even an electric car that shuts down completely, except for the anti-theft system, incurs losses, though of course far less than a Tesla.

Now we need to calculate a balance between summer and winter. It may come as a surprise to you that the average temperature in 2019, a year that was perceived as particularly warm, was nevertheless only a little over 10°C. Overall, we therefore estimate that electric cars experience additional losses of 10 percent, losses at the charging station (including, and especially, those caused by fast charging), within the car itself, and due to standstill.

Until now, diesel might have been a slightly better deal, but now electric cars are slightly preferred.

Once again, there are differences of opinion regarding how much of the Model 3's 75 kWh battery capacity is actually usable. We're assuming 70 kWh here, even though some people claim to have achieved as much as 73 kWh. After all, that's only a 6.7 percent difference, even though people still assume there's at least a 10 percent difference between gross and net, including manufacturers, who provide both figures.

Finally, let's be a little generous and continue to assume that an electric car arrives at the charging station with the same amount of remaining energy as a car with an internal combustion engine arrives at the gas station. We're driving with both cars completely empty-even just based on the calculation. In that case, the Model 3 has a range of 412 km. To do that, the diesel would need a 20.6-liter tank. So it's not the case that you can convert the calorific value of diesel fuel to battery capacity. Because then the 70 kWh available in the Model 3, at 10 kW/L, would correspond almost exactly to 7 liters of diesel. So compared to an electric car, it consumes three times as much.

Why is that? Of course, it has to do with losses again. The internal combustion engine produces significantly more of them during operation. Kinetic energy and heat escape from the exhaust, and, of course, from the cooling system and the powertrain components themselves, because there is more of it there and more friction is generated in those areas. In contrast, the battery cooling requirements for electric cars are significantly lower.

It has always been clear (except in the case of the VW Beetle) that a car that doesn't heat well without additional aids might actually be more fuel-efficient. Just look at the difference between modern gasoline and diesel engines. But on the other hand, simply adding up all the emissions from a diesel-powered car, which already exceed 60 percent from the engine alone and may reach as high as 90 percent when you factor in the vehicle's impact on the road, isn't fair either.

Still, today's electric cars deserve some credit, because 20 liters of gas is equivalent to 17 kg. If we add a maximum of 13 kg for the tank and auxiliary equipment, we arrive at 30 kg. With electric cars, he battery always weighs the same, whether it's full or empty. In the chapter on battery technology in 2020, we assumed that the current battery weight of the Model 3 is 480 kg. The fact that it manages to get by on just 17 kWh/100 km despite this load is quite an achievement.

However, once again, one should not assume that a Model 3 with a diesel engine is 480 kg – 30 kg = 450 kg more lightweight. Then one would be ignoring the enormous additional weight of the diesel engine and the attached components, such as the exhaust system with emission control. Nevertheless, electric cars are significantly heavier, even if they have a smaller battery on board.

And finally, a little adventure. It's about the space required per kWh. At perhaps two-thirds of a kWh per liter at present, this can still be estimated fairly accurately. But not as precise as that one, when you take into account all the necessary protective and cooling components. We therefore assume, somewhat boldly, a total of 500 kWh per liter.

That would mean the Model 3's 75 kWh battery would have a volume of 150 liters. Coincidentally, it's again one-third the size of a combustion engine tank, although this one fits much better and is therefore easier to accommodate. However, AdBlue tanks are currently growing enormously in size. And, for another reason, it doesn’t stop at just one-third, for instance, because an electric vehicle also has space for a small luggage compartment above the motor at the front.


kfz-tech.de/YeD16


kfz-tech.de/YeD17







Sidemap - Technik Imprint E-Mail Datenschutz Sidemap - Hersteller